Oreo’s Candy Corn Oreos didn’t turn out so well, but today the cookie company released an Oreo flavor for another candy that doesn’t belong in an Oreo: Swedish Fish.
The limited-edition flavor sandwiches Swedish Fish-flavored creme between two classic chocolate Oreo cookies. You can buy the new cookie, which The Impulsive Buy describes as a “crispy fruit medicine puree,” today at Kroger, where they’re being exclusively sold. Or, if you don’t live near a Kroger, but want to try the delicious cough-syrupy treat, some people are selling it on eBay.
An Oreo spokesperson told TIME the following:
We know that consumers enjoy variety when it comes to snacking so we create all of our limited-edition flavors to provide surprising new twists people know and love and on occasion, create unexpected and unique flavor combinations that people may never have thought were possible, including our latest from the Wonder Vault, Swedish Fish Flavored Creme Oreo Cookies.
He’s right—we certainly never thought this was possible, and can only imagine the decision was made like so: