Paddy Moloney (1938-2021): The Chieftains Founder Changed Irish Music Forever

Music Features Paddy Moloney
Share Tweet Submit Pin
Paddy Moloney (1938-2021): The Chieftains Founder Changed Irish Music Forever

Paddy Moloney, the founder and leader of Ireland’s Chieftains, was short in stature, high-pitched in voice, and always bubbling with jokes and laughter. But Moloney, who died Monday at age 83, was a masterful piper and composer whose dead-serious vision lifted traditional Irish folk music out of the obscure pubs and wedding halls to which it had been relegated and made it a global phenomenon.

It’s easy to forget how neglected this music had become in 1964, when The Chieftains released their first, eponymous album. Not only in Dublin and Galway, but also in the Irish diaspora towns of London, Boston and Melbourne, the old reels, jigs, waltzes and airs were rarely played for a paying audience—and even then, usually in diluted form. Music-hall pop music and nascent rock ‘n’ roll had pushed the folk tunes to the margins.

Moloney would change all that. He would prove that The Chieftains and their music were substantial enough to be played by symphony orchestras, evocative enough to work as the scores for big-budget films, popular enough to be joined by Sting, Willie Nelson and The Rolling Stones, and universal enough to work in China and Spain. But none of this happened overnight.

“When I was 16 and learning to play the pipes,” he told me in 1985, “I got a great slagging from friends of mine. Nowadays, they’re coming up to me and saying, ‘Can you get tickets for my friends in Toronto or Baltimore?’ We’ve swung things around, gotten people away from that tearjerker stuff. We’ve helped people recognize their own culture.”

Moloney grew up in North Dublin in a family full of traditional musicians, and he spent many summers in the mountains of County Laois without running water or electricity, but with plenty of the old tunes. He started on the tin whistle at age six and the Uilleann pipes at eight. These pipes are different from the more familiar Scottish bagpipes; the Irish pipes don’t rely on blowing air, but on squeezing a bellows with one’s elbow. As a result, the airflow is drier and more consistent, creating a sweeter, more controllable sound.

By the time he was 20, Moloney was a master piper, but he was frustrated by the lack of opportunities for developing his craft. Traditional Irish music was mostly played in impromptu “sessions,” where anyone who showed up would play along on a limited set of tunes that everyone knew. This format was democratic and spontaneous, but it didn’t allow for new compositions or ensemble arrangements.

In 1959, though, Dublin composer Sean O’Riada created the soundtrack music for the Irish film Mise Eire (I Am Ireland) by weaving folk melodies and folk instruments into a symphonic score. It was a big success and prompted him to form Ceoltóirí Chualann, a classical chamber group that did the same thing. Moloney, fiddler Sean Keane and tin whistler Sean Potts were members of that group, but they decided they’d be better off if they chucked the classical trimmings altogether and fully devoted themselves to folk music. Irish poet John Montague named them The Chieftains.

“I wanted to create a folk-chamber group,” Moloney told me in 2012. “I wanted to push this folk art a little further along. I brought together all the instruments associated with traditional Irish folk music and I did arrangements for different combinations of all these instruments. By taking tunes and adding these new combinations and new riffs, we did something that no one had done before.”

It was tough going for a while, and it wasn’t until 1975, when The Chieftains played London’s Royal Albert Hall and Stanley Kubrick used five of their pieces in the score for his movie Barry Lyndon, that The Chieftains became “overnight” stars and could quit their day jobs. They had finally made it, but Moloney’s ambitions were larger still.

“I was never happy with whatever was happening at the time,” he told me in 1984. “Something was always missing. I was always messing around with the harmonies, which the purists frowned on. I would create harmonies by pairing two whistles or two fiddles. I encouraged improvising as long as it stayed in the traditional vein.”

By 1980, The Chieftains had settled into their most famous lineup: Moloney, Keane, fiddler Martin Fay, flutist Matt Molloy, harper Derek Bell and singer/percussionist Kevin Conneff. Bell played the ancient Celtic lap harp and Conneff the ancient Irish frame drum, the Bodhrán. Moloney was adamant about not using fretted instruments in the group, insisting that a guitar or bouzouki would spoil the special sound of medieval instruments put to modern use.

Ironically, The Chieftains’ success inspired dozens of terrific new Celtic folk bands to blossom in Ireland and Scotland, almost all of them featuring the guitar and/or bouzouki. These bands—including The Bothy Band, Planxty, Silly Wizard, Boys of the Lough, Patrick Street, Ossian, Tannahill Weavers, Battlefield Band, Relativity, De Dannan and Altan—were under the influence of Bob Dylan and The Beatles, and thus put more emphasis on lyrics and guitars than The Chieftains did.

These younger groups couldn’t have succeeded without the popularity of the older band, but they took the traditional music in a different direction from Moloney’s. It was not difficult to embrace all of them. In fact, when founding members Sean Potts and Michael Tubridy left The Chieftains in 1979, Moloney replaced them with another flutist, Matt Molloy, who had played with The Bothy Band and Planxty.

Moreover, Moloney had no problem with collaborating with guest artists who played guitar and sang their own songs. The first collaboration with a major pop star was the 1988 album, Irish Heartbeat, with Van Morrison. The vocalist, who grew up in Belfast imitating Ray Charles and Sam Cooke, had turned increasingly in recent years to the spiritual and musical themes of his native land. He had worked to fashion his own Celtic mythology, conjuring up a vision of “Wild Billy Yeats” as a rhythm and blues singer, and of “Tir Na Nog” as a Celtic utopia one could reach by climbing a mountain from an old Irish church.

The Chieftains’ approach to the tradition, by contrast, wasn’t so much conservative as it was conservationist. That is, they sought to preserve the timeless, classical qualities of a richly endowed music. Afforded the rare luxury of a stable lineup and full-time work, the six virtuosos blended a top chamber-music group without ever sounding dry or academic.

Irish Heartbeat became something much more than a mere guest appearance, because Morrison and The Chieftains refused to compromise their differing slants on Celtic music. Instead each side stuck to its beliefs, and the resulting tension fills the eight traditional songs and two Morrison originals with thrilling drama.

You can hear that tension on “Raglan Road,” the album’s greatest triumph. Patrick Kavanaugh’s brilliant lyrics about loving the wrong woman are set to a lovely traditional tune, and The Chieftains’ twin fiddles and warbling pipes make it clear this is an ageless, universal tale.

But as Morrison wrestles with the vocal—growling, stuttering, whispering, sighing—he makes it just as clear that the universality of heartbreak doesn’t matter to the heartbroken. He is singing about a very particular pain. When the singer hushes the band with a hissing “sh-h-h” and whispers with a scary intimacy, “On a quiet street, where old ghosts meet, I see her walking now away from me,” it raises the hairs on one’s neck.

The album proved so successful that when The Chieftains did a Christmas album in 1991, The Bells of Dublin, they enlisted Elvis Costello, Jackson Browne, Kate & Anna McGarrigle, Marianne Faithfull, Nanci Griffith and Rickie Lee Jones as singers. The Chieftains did three different albums with country singers such as Ricky Skaggs, Vince Gill, Rosanne Cash, John Prine and Emmylou Harris. The Chieftains’ most recent album was 2012’s Voice of Ages, featuring The Decemberists, the Carolina Chocolate Drops, Bon Iver and the Pistol Annies.

“When I did those albums in Nashville,” Moloney added in 2012, “I realized how the roots of country music relate to Ireland. ‘Down the Old Plank Road,’ which became the title for two of the albums, goes all the way back to the Carter Family, and I recognized the melody as a very old Irish song we learned in school at eight or nine. When it got over to the States, they added guitar and fiddle to turn it into a two-step. You can hear the similarities between our music and musics from all over the world, even Brazilian songs and African drumming.”

Moloney explored those cross-cultural connections by doing a 1996 album, Santiago, with Galician musicians of northwest Spain; a 1987 album, Celtic Wedding, with Breton musicians from northern France; and a 1985 album, The Chieftains in China, with various Chinese folk orchestras.

“I thought there might be problems with pitch and harmonies,” Moloney said in 1985 of the Chinese sessions, “but all my doubts were dispelled at the first rehearsal. The instruments blended beautifully right from the start. Once we heard that, everyone relaxes, and soon the typical musicians’ jokes were going all day.”

It was proof of Moloney’s abiding faith that folk musics from around the world are united by the need of farmers to mark the changing seasons, to mourn deaths and wars, to celebrate harvests and weddings. Folk instruments prior to the 20th century were by necessity acoustic and portable, so there are bound to be commonalities. And that folk music can not only cross boundaries of geography, but also time. Music that was powerful in the 16th century can be just as powerful in the 21st if it’s presented the right way. Moloney’s genius was in making that too obvious to ignore.